United Kingdom general election, 1931
* The Labour total includes six unendorsed candidates associated with the Independent Labour Party. Of these, three retook the Labour whip during the parliament. The ILP would contest the next two elections entirely separately from Labour.
|1924 election • MPs|
|1929 election • MPs|
|1931 election • MPs|
|1935 election • MPs|
|1945 election • MPs|
The United Kingdom general election held on Tuesday 27 October 1931 saw a landslide election victory for the National Government which had been formed two months previously after the collapse of the previous Labour government. The bulk of the National Government's support came from the Conservative Party, and the Conservatives won 470 seats. The Labour party suffered its greatest defeat, losing four out of five seats compared with the previous election. The Liberal Party, split into three factions, continued to shrink and the Liberal National faction never reunited. Ivor Bulmer-Thomas said the results "were the most astonishing in the history of the British party system". It was the last election where one party (the Conservatives) received an absolute majority of the votes cast and the last UK general election not to take place on a Thursday.
After battling with the Great Depression for two years, Ramsay MacDonald's Labour government had been faced with a sudden budget crisis in August 1931. The cabinet deadlocked over its response, with several influential members such as Arthur Henderson unwilling to support the budget cuts (in particular a cut in the rate of unemployment benefit) which were pressed by the civil service and opposition parties. Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Snowden refused to consider deficit spending or tariffs as alternative solutions. When the government resigned, MacDonald was encouraged by King George V to form an all-party National Government to deal with the immediate crisis.
The initial hope that the government would hold office for a few weeks and then dissolve to return to ordinary party politics were frustrated when the government was forced to remove the Pound sterling from the Gold standard; meanwhile the Labour Party expelled all those who were supporting the government. The Conservatives began pressing for the National Government to fight an election as a combined unit, and MacDonald's supporters from the Labour Party formed a National Labour organisation to support him; MacDonald came to endorse an early election to take advantage of Labour's unpopularity. However the Liberals were sceptical about an election and had to be persuaded. Former Liberal leader David Lloyd George firmly opposed the decision to call an election and urged his colleagues to withdraw from the National Government.
A main issue was the Conservatives' wish to introduce protectionist trade policies. This issue not only divided the government from the opposition but also divided the parties in the National Government: the majority of Liberals, led by Sir Herbert Samuel, were opposed and supported free trade, but on the eve of the election a faction known as Liberal Nationals under the leadership of Sir John Simon was formed who were willing to support protectionist trade policies. In order to preserve the Liberals within the National Government, the government itself did not endorse a policy but appealed for a "Doctor's Mandate" to do whatever was necessary to rescue the economy. Individual Conservative candidates did support protective tariffs.
Labour campaigned on opposition to public spending cuts, but found it difficult to defend the record of the party's former government and the fact that most of the cuts had been agreed before it fell. Historian Andrew Thorpe argues that Labour lost credibility by 1931 as unemployment soared, especially in coal, textiles, shipbuilding, and steel. The working class increasingly lost confidence in the ability of Labour to solve the most pressing problem.
The 2.5 million Irish Catholics in England and Scotland were a major factor in the Labour base in many industrial areas. The Catholic Church had previously tolerated the Labour Party, and denied that it represented true socialism. However, the bishops by 1930 had grown increasingly alarmed at Labour's policies toward Communist Russia, toward birth control and especially toward funding Catholic schools. They warned its members. The Catholic shift against Labour and in favour of the National government played a major role in Labour's losses.
In the event, the Labour vote fell sharply, and the National Government won a landslide majority. Although the overwhelming majority of the Government MPs were Conservatives under the leadership of Stanley Baldwin, Ramsay MacDonald remained Prime Minister in the new National government. The Liberals lacked the funds to contest the full range of seats, but still won almost as many constituencies as the Labour Party.
|Party||Leader||Standing||Elected||Gained||Unseated||Net||% of total||%||No.||Net %|
|Conservative||Stanley Baldwin||518||470||207||0||+ 207||76.4||55.0||11,377,022||+ 16.9|
|Liberal||Herbert Samuel||112||33||16||7||+ 9||5.4||6.5||1,346,571||− 17.1|
|Liberal National||John Simon||41||35||10||2||+ 8||5.7||3.7||761,705||N/A|
|National Labour||Ramsay MacDonald||20||13||3||5||− 2||2.1||1.5||316,741||N/A|
|National Government (total)||694||554||239||21||+ 218||90.1||67.2||13,902,232|
|Labour||Arthur Henderson||490||46||2||208||− 206||7.5||29.4||6,081,826||− 7.7|
|Ind. Labour Party||Fenner Brockway||19||3||0||6||− 6||0.5||1.2||239,280||N/A|
|Other unendorsed Labour||N/A||6||3||0||1||− 1||0.5||0.3||64,549||N/A|
|NI Labour||Jack Beattie||1||0||0||0||0||0.0||0.0||9,410||N/A|
|Labour total||516||52||0||213||− 213||8.5||30.6||6,395,065||− 6.5|
|Opposition Liberal||David Lloyd George||6||4||0||1||− 1||0.7||0.5||106,106||N/A|
|Nationalist||Joseph Devlin||3||2||0||1||− 1||0.3||0.4||72,530||+ 0.3|
|Communist||Harry Pollitt||26||0||0||0||0||0||0.3||69,692||+ 0.1|
|New Party||Oswald Mosley||24||0||0||4||− 4||0||0.2||36,377||N/A|
|National (Scotland)||Roland Muirhead||5||0||0||0||0||0||0.1||20,954||+ 0.1|
|Independent Labour||N/A||2||0||0||1||− 1||0||0.1||18,200||0.0|
|Scottish Prohibition||Edwin Scrymgeour||1||0||0||1||− 1||0||0.1||16,114||0.0|
|Liverpool Protestant||H. D. Longbottom||1||0||0||0||0||0||0.0||7,834||N/A|
|Agricultural Party||J. F. Wright||1||0||0||0||0||0||0.0||6,993||N/A|
|Independent Liberal||N/A||1||0||0||0||0||0||0.0||2,578||− 0.1|
|Plaid Cymru||Saunders Lewis||2||0||0||0||0||0||0.0||2,050||0.0|
Note: Seat changes are compared with the dissolution and are based on "The Times House of Commons 1931" p. 134–6 with revisions from F. W. S. Craig.
Results by constituency
These are available at the PoliticsResources website, a link to which is given below.
- ↑ Ivor Bulmer-Thomas, The Growth of the British Party System Volume II 1924–1964 (1967) p 76
- ↑ Andrew Thorpe, "The Industrial Meaning of 'Gradualism': The Labour Party and Industry, 1918–1931." The Journal of British Studies 35#1 (1996): 84-113.
- ↑ Neil Riddell, "The Catholic Church and the Labour Party, 1918–1931." Twentieth Century British History 8.2 (1997): 165-193.
- ↑ http://www.parliament.uk/documents/commons/lib/research/rp2008/rp08-012.pdf
- Ball, Stuart. Baldwin and the Conservative Party: The Crisis of 1929–31 (Yale University Press, 1988)
- Bassett, R. Nineteen Thirty-One Political Crisis (1958) online
- Bulmer-Thomas, Ivor. The Growth of the British Party System Volume II 1924–1964 (1967) pp. 68–82
- Close, D. H. "The realignment of the British electorate in 1931." History 67.221 (1982): 393-404.
- F. W. S. Craig, British Electoral Facts: 1832–1987
- Thorpe, Andrew. The British General Election of 1931 (Oxford, 1991) DOI:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198202189.001.0001 online
- Thorpe, Andrew. "Arthur Henderson and the British political crisis of 1931." Historical Journal 31#1 (1988): 117-139.
- Toye, Richard. "Plan or Perish: 1931 and its Impact" in Toye, The Labour Party and the Planned Economy, 1931-1951 (2003) pp. 34-64 http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7722/j.ctt81jtf.7
- United Kingdom election results - summary results 1885–1979
- 1931 election results by constituency
- 1931 Conservative manifesto
- 1931 Labour manifesto
- 1931 Liberal manifesto