Saint Ninian as intercessor ("Ora pro nobis, Sancte Niniane"). Donor portrait in the Book of Hours of the Virgin and Saint Ninian, 15th century
|Apostle to the Southern Picts|
|Major shrine||Whithorn Priory|
Saint Ninian is a Christian saint first mentioned in the 8th century as being an early missionary among the Pictish peoples of what is now Scotland. For this reason he is known as the Apostle to the Southern Picts, and there are numerous dedications to him in those parts of Scotland with a Pictish heritage, throughout the Scottish Lowlands, and in parts of Northern England with a Northumbrian heritage. In Scotland, Ninian is also known as Ringan, and as Trynnian in Northern England.
Ninian's major shrine was at Whithorn in Galloway, where he is associated with the Candida Casa (Latin for 'White House'). Nothing is known about his teachings, and there is no unchallenged authority for information about his life.
A link between the Ninian of tradition and a person who actually appears in the historical record is not yet confirmed, though Finnian of Moville has gained traction as a leading candidate. This article discusses the particulars and origins of what has come to be known as the "traditional" stories of Saint Ninian.
The Southern Picts, for whom Ninian is held to be the apostle, are the Picts south of the mountains known as the Mounth, which cross Scotland north of the Firths of Clyde and Forth. That they had once been Christian is known from a 5th-century mention of them by Saint Patrick in his Letter to Coroticus, where he refers to them as 'apostate Picts'. Patrick could not have been referring to the Northern Picts who were converted by Saint Columba in the 6th century because they were not yet Christian, and thus could not be called 'apostate'. Northumbria had established a bishopric among the Southern Picts at Abercorn in 681, under Bishop Trumwine. This effort was abandoned shortly after the Picts defeated the Northumbrians at the Battle of Dun Nechtain in 685.
Christianity had flourished in Galloway in the 6th century. By the time of Bede's account in 731, the Northumbrians had enjoyed an unbroken relationship with Galloway for a century or longer, beginning with the Northumbrian predecessor state of Bernicia. The full nature of the relationship is uncertain. Also at this time, Northumbria was establishing bishoprics in its sphere of influence, to be subordinate to the Northumbrian Archbishop of York. One such bishopric was established at Whithorn in 731, and Bede's account serves to support the legitimacy of the new Northumbrian bishopric. The Bernician name hwit ærn is Old English for the Latin candida casa, or 'white house' in modern English, and it has survived as the modern name of Whithorn.
There is as yet no unchallenged connection of the historical record to the person who was Bede's Ninian. However, the unlikelihood that the reputable historian Bede invented Ninian without some basis in the historical record, combined with an increased knowledge of Ireland's early saints and Whithorn's early Christian connections, has led to serious scholarly efforts to find Bede's basis. James Henthorn Todd, in his 1855 publication of the Leabhar Imuinn (The Book of Hymns of the Ancient Church of Ireland), suggested that it was Finnian of Moville, and that view has gained traction among modern scholars.
The earliest mention of Ninian of Whithorn is in a short passage of The Ecclesiastical History of the English People by the Northumbrian monk Bede in ca. 731. The 9th-century poem Miracula Nyniae Episcopi records some of the miracles attributed to him. A Life of Saint Ninian (Vita Sancti Niniani) was written around 1160 by Ailred of Rievaulx, and in 1639 James Ussher discusses Ninian in his Brittanicarum Ecclesiarum Antiquitates. These are the sources of information about Ninian of Whithorn, and all provide seemingly innocuous personal details about his life. However, there is no unchallenged historical evidence to support any of their stories, and all sources had political and religious agendas that were served by their accounts of Saint Ninian (discussed below).
Tradition holds that Ninian was a Briton who had studied in Rome, that he established an episcopal see at the Candida Casa in Whithorn, that he named the see for Saint Martin of Tours, that he converted the southern Picts to Christianity, and that he is buried at Whithorn. Variations of the story add that he had actually met Saint Martin, that his father was a Christian king, and that he was buried in a stone sarcophagus near the altar of his church. Further variations assert that he left for Ireland, and died there in 432. Dates for his birth are derived from the traditional mention of Saint Martin, who died in 397.
Bede's contribution (ca. 731)
Bede says that Ninian (whose name he only renders in the ablative case Nynia) was a Briton who had been instructed in Rome; that he made his church of stone, which was unusual among the Britons; that his episcopal see was named after Saint Martin of Tours; that he preached to and converted the southern Picts; that his base was in a place called " Ad Candidam Casam", which was in the province of the Bernicians; and that he was buried there, along with many other saints.
Bede's information is minimal and he does not claim it as fact, asserting only that he is passing on "traditional" information. He provides the first historical reference to Saint Ninian, in a passing reference contained in the final part of a single paragraph.
Aelred's contribution (ca. 1160)
Leaving aside the tales regarding miracles, in the Vita Sancti Niniani Aelred includes the following incidental information regarding Saint Ninian: that his father was a Christian king; that he was consecrated a bishop in Rome and that he met Saint Martin in Tours; that Saint Martin sent masons with him on his homeward journey, at his request; that these masons built a church of stone, situated on the shore, and that on learning of Saint Martin's death, Ninian dedicated the church to him; that a certain rich and powerful "King Tuduvallus" was converted by him; that he died after having converted the Picts and returned home, being buried in a stone sarcophagus near the altar of his church; and that he had once travelled with his brother, named "Plebia".
Aelred said that in addition to finding information about Ninian in Bede, he took much additional information for his Life of S. Ninian from a source written in a "barbarous language"; there is no further information about this text. Aelred wrote his Life of S. Ninian sometime after spending ten years at the Scottish court and thus had close connections both to the Scottish royal family and to Fergus of Galloway (who would resurrect the Bishopric of Galloway), all of whom would have been pleased to have a manuscript with such a glowing description of a Galwegian and Scottish saint. His work is what Thomas Heffernan refers to as a "sacred biography," probably intended for a politically ambitious audience.
Ussher's contribution (1639)
Ussher says that Ninian left Candida Casa for Cluayn-coner in Ireland, and eventually died in Ireland; that his mother was a Spanish princess; that his father wished to regain him after having assented to his training for an ecclesiastical state; that a bell comes from heaven to call together his disciples; that a wooden church was raised by him, with beams delivered by stags; and that a harper with no experience at architecture was the builder of the church. He adds that a smith and his son, named respectively "Terna" and "Wyn", witnessed a miracle by Ninian and that the saint was granted lands to be called "Wytterna".
In addition, Skene attributes the "traditional" date of Ninian's death (16 September 432) ultimately to Ussher's Life of Ninian, noting that the date is "without authority."
Ussher's contribution is often disparaged, as he both invented fictitious histories and misquoted legitimate manuscripts to suit his own purposes. Still, he had access to legitimate manuscripts, and he has contributed to some versions of the traditional stories.
Others who wrote of Saint Ninian used the accounts of Bede, Aelred, or Ussher, or used derivatives of them in combination with information from various manuscripts. This includes John Capgrave (1393 – 1464), John of Tinmouth (fl. ca. 1366), John Colgan (d. ca. 1657), and many others, up to the present day.
The anonymously written 8th century hagiographic Miracula Nynie Episcopi (Miracles of Bishop Ninian) is discounted as a non-historical account, and copies are not widely extant.
Dedications to St Ninian
Dedications to Saint Ninian are expressions of respect for the good works that are attributed to him, and the authenticity of the stories about him are not relevant to that point. Almost all of the dedications have their origins in the medieval era, after Aelred wrote his account.
Dedications on the Isle of Man date from the time of medieval Scottish dominance, and are not natively inspired.
There are dedications to St. Ninian in East Donegal and Belfast; and a spot formerly on the shore of Belfast Lough was traditionally known as St. Ninian's point, where the missionary reputedly landed after a voyage from Scotland. These connections reflect a strong Ulster-Scots heritage in both areas of Ulster.
- St. Ninian's Cave, Glasserton, Wigtownshire by Sir Herbert Maxwell. 1885
- Entrance to St. Ninian's Cave
- Votives at St. Ninian's Cave entrance
- The Clog-rinny, or Bell of St. Ninian.
- Burgh of Nairn Seal, depicting St. Ninian (1906).
- Burgh of Whithorn Seal, depicting St. Ninian (1906).
- Todd, James Henthorn (1863), "The Epistle on Coroticus", St. Patrick, Apostle of Ireland, Dublin: Hodges, Smith, & Co. (published 1864), p. 384
- Maxwell, Herbert Eustace (1887), Studies in the Topography of Galloway, Edinburgh: David Douglas, p. 21 – Excavations at the predecessor building of Whithorn Priory, and at Saint Ninian's Cave, had discovered Celtic crosses from this period. Old English runes found on them are later additions.
- Todd, James Henthorn, ed. (1855), "Note B: St. Finnian of Maghbile", Leabhar Imuinn (The Book of Hymns of the Ancient Church of Ireland), Dublin: The Irish Archaeological and Celtic Society, pp. 98–108
- Yorke, Barbara (2007), The Conversion of Britain: Religion, Politics and Society in Britain, 600–800, Religion, Politics and Society in Britain (ed. Keith Robbins), Harlow: Pearson Education Limited, p. 113, ISBN 0-582-77292-3
- Christopher Howse (6 June 2014). "Not a saint but a spelling mistake". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 9 June 2014.
- Bede & 731:271, 273 Book III Chapter IV, When the nation of the Picts received the faith
- Forbes 1874:frontispiece The Historians of Scotland: The Lives of S. Ninian and S. Kentigern
- Forbes 1874:1–26 The Life of S. Ninian by Ailred
- Dowden 1894:23–32 In The Life of St. Ninian
- Thomas Heffernan, Sacred Biography: Saints and their Biographers in the Middle Ages, Oxford University Press, 1992.
- Forbes 1874:iv-v Introduction to the Life of S. Ninian
- Ussher 1639:199–209, 228, 251 — claims regarding Ninian in his Life of Ninian, in Latin
- Skene 1887:3–4 In The Churches in the West
- Newman 1845:11 "The Irish life referred to by Archbishop Ussher does not appear entitled to much consideration" in St. Ninian's early days, for example; and elsewhere in the book.
- Hardy 1862:44 "The Irish Life was written long after Ninian's death, by an author of little discretion, who wished to adjust the conduct of the Saint to the usages of his own time." in the footnote, for example.
- for example, see Bridgett, Thomas Edward (1881), "Catholicity of North-Britons", History of the Holy Eucharist in Great Britain, I, London: C. Kegan Paul & Co, p. 55 (footnote) — Ussher printed a manuscript of the letters of Alcuin, which contained a request for the intercession of Saint Ninian; however, Ussher edited the manuscript to change parts of it, and among his changes was the omission of Alcuin's request, but leaving other parts of it intact.
- Lawrie, Archibald Campbell (1905), "Letter of Alcuin to the Monks of Candid Casa, A.D. 782-804", Early Scottish Charters Prior to A.D. 1153, Glasgow: James Maclehose and Sons, pp. 226–27
- Hardy 1862 throughout the book
- Koch, John T. (2005), "Ninian, St.", Celtic Culture: A Historical Encyclopedia, ABC-CLIO, p. 1358, ISBN 978-1-85109-440-0
- Scott 1905:378–388 Nynia in Northern Pictland
- Forbes 1874:xiii-xvii List of dedications to Saint Ninian, The Historians of Scotland: The Lives of S. Ninian and S. Kentigern
- Moore 1890:214–15, 306 In Distinctive Affixes
- Mackinlay 1904 mentions are throughout the book.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Saint Ninian.|
- Bede (731), Giles, J. A., ed., The Miscellaneous Works of Venerable Bede, II, London: Whittaker and Co. (published 1863)
- Dowden, John (1894), "The Life of St. Ninian", The Celtic Church in Scotland, London: Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, pp. 23–32
- Forbes, Alexander Penrose (1874), The Historians of Scotland: The Lives of S. Ninian and S. Kentigern, V, Edinburgh: Edmonston and Douglas
- Hardy, Thomas Duffus (1862), Descriptive Catalogue of Materials Relating to the History of Great Britain and Ireland, I, London: Longman, green, Longman, and Roberts — many references to, and comments upon, sources of information
- Healy, John (1890), Insula Sanctorum Et Doctorum (Ireland's Ancient Schools and Scholars) (5th ed.), Dublin: Sealy, Bryers & Walker (published 1908)
- Lanigan, John (1822), An Ecclesiastical History of Ireland, I, Dublin
- Mackinlay, James Murray (1904), Influence of the Pre-Reformation Church on Scottish Place-Names, Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons
- Moore, Arthur William (1890), The Surnames and Place-names of the Isle of Man, London: Elliot Stock
- Newman, John Henry; Hutton, Arthur Wollaston (1845), Lives of the English Saints: St. Aelred, Abbot of Rievaulx, London: James Toovey
- Scott, Archibald Black (July 1905), The Scottish Historical Review, Glasgow: James Maclehose and Sons (published 1905), II (8): 378–388 Missing or empty
- Skene, William Forbes (1887), Celtic Scotland: A History of Ancient Alban, II (2nd ed.), Edinburgh: David Douglas
- Ussher, James (1639), "Britannicarum Ecclesiarum Antiquitates", The Whole Works of the Most Reverend James Ussher, D. D., VI, Dublin
- Bateson, Mary (1894). "Mo-nennius". In Lee, Sidney. Dictionary of National Biography. 38. London: Smith, Elder & Co.
- Broun, Dauvit E. "Ninian [St Ninian] (fl. 5th-6th cent.)". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/20198. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)