Racism in Italy
Racism in Italy deals with the relations of Italians and outgroups in the history of Italy. Racism like bigotry is encountered in most societies, and Italy has been no exception. Italians, though a unified sense of national-corporate identity as found in the classic European nations to the north has been historically fragile, have long prided themselves on an absence of racial enmity. For decades after unification, the country lacked a cohesive national identity, and hostility to outsiders was mainly a matter of regional antipathies. Italy's colonial adventures led to an upsurge in explicit racial antipathies for the peoples colonized. Under Benito Mussolini's fascist state, once the régime consolidated its pact with Nazi Germany, anti-Semitic laws were passed, as were laws prohibiting internal migration under certain circumstances. The post-war mass migrations from the south towards the industrialized north engendered a degree of anti-southern prejudice. A wave of immigration by extra-comunitari (non-EU immigrants. The word has strong undertones of exclusion) from the late 80s, gave rise to political movements, like the Northern League, hostile to both southern Italians and clandestini (illegal immigrants) from areas south of the Mediterranean. In 2011, a report by Human Rights Watch pointed to growing indications of a rise in xenophobia within Italian society.
In Medieval Italy, slavery was widespread, but was justified more often on religious rather than racial grounds. Almost all slaves in Genoa belonged to non-European races; the situation was different in Venice and Palermo, where emancipated slaves were considered free citizens in the 13th century.
19th and early 20th centuries
Lombroso and scientific racism in Italy
Scientific racism was popularized in Italy by criminologist Cesare Lombroso. Lombroso's theory of atavism compared white civilization and other races with "primitive" or "savage" societies. His theories connecting physiognomy to criminal behavior explicitly blamed higher homicide rates in southern Italy on the influence of African and Asian blood on its population. In 1871 Lombroso published The White Man and the Man of Color, aimed at showing that the white man was superior in every respect to other races. Lombroso explicitly stated his belief in white supremacy: "only we whites have achieved the most perfect symmetry in the forms of the body [...] possess a true musical art [...] have proclaimed the freedom of the slave [...] have procured the liberty of thought". Lombroso equated the criminal tendencies of the white population to residual "blackness". The ideas of Lombroso about race would spread around Europe at the end of the 19th century.
Lombroso, who also wrote extensively on the topic of anti-Semitism in Europe and attacked anti-Semitic racial theory, distinguished between European Jews, as generally "Aryan", and traditionalist Jews whose religious practices he excoriated, and regarded southerners in Italy as "atavistic".
Other scholars of scientific racism
Other Italian anthropologists and sociologists also explored Lombroso's path of scientific racism. Alfredo Niceforo followed Lombroso's physiognomical approach, but in 1906 published a curious racial theory where both blond pigmentation of hair and dark skin were considered signs of degeneration, with the Italian race in a positive middle ground. Niceforo held these views as late as 1952, claiming that "Negroid and Mongoloid types were more frequent in the lower classes". In 1907 anthropologist Ridolfo Livi attempted to show that Mongolian facial features correlated with poorer populations. However, he maintained that the superiority of the Italian race was proven by its capability to positively assimilate other ethnic components.
Anti-Semitism before 1938
Italian Jews had one of the highest rates of integration in mixed marriages in the diaspora. Jews fervently supported the Risorgimento, identified as Italian nationalists, proved valiant as soldiers in WW1, and, in terms of their relatively small numerical presence within the population generally, formed a disproportionate part of the Fascist party from its beginnings down to 1938. It is still debated whether Italian Fascism was originally anti-Semitic. Mussolini originally distinguished his position Hitler's fanatical racism while affirming he himself was a Zionist. More broadly, he even proposed building a mosque in Rome as a sign that Italy was the Protector of Islam, a move blocked by a horrified Pope. German propagandists often derided what they called Italy's "Kosher Fascism". There were however some Fascists, Roberto Farinacci and Giovanni Preziosi being prime examples, who held fringe extremist racist views before the alliance with Nazi Germany. Preziosi was the first to publish an Italian edition of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion,in 1921, which was published almost simultaneously with a version issued by Umberto Benigni in supplements to Fede e Ragione.. The book however had little impact until the mid-1930s.
It has also been indicated Benito Mussolini had his own, if somewhat different from Nazi, brand of racist views. Mussolini was quoted as saying: "the white man has to subdue the black, brown and yellow races."
Mussolini had held the view that a small contingent of Italian Jews had lived in Italy "since the days of the Kings of Rome" (a reference to the Bené Roma) and should "remain undisturbed". One of Mussolini's mistresses, Margherita Sarfatti, was Jewish. There were even some Jews in the National Fascist Party, such as Ettore Ovazza who founded the Jewish Fascist paper La Nostra Bandiera in 1935. Mussolini once declared "Anti-Semitism does not exist in Italy... Italians of Jewish birth have shown themselves good citizens and they fought bravely in [World War I]."
Despite the presence of a Fascist regime, Italy in the first half of the 1930s was seen as a safe haven by some Jewish refugees. The country hosting up to 11,000 persecuted Jews, including 2,806 of German descent. However, as early as 1934 there had been removals of Jewish personnel from institutions and state organizations. 1934 also saw press campaigns against anti-fascist Jews, equating them with Zionists. Between 1936 and 1938, Fascist regime-endorsed anti-Semitic propaganda was mounting in the press and even in graffiti. Equally, scholars of eugenetics, statistics, anthropology and demographics began to outline racist theories.
In 1937, the Second Italo-Ethiopian War led to the first Fascist Laws promoting explicit racial discrimination. These were the laws against madamato – that is, the concubinage between Italians and African women in occupied territories. The penalty for madamato was from one to five years of prison. Remarkably, one of the justifications of the laws was that such relationships were abusive towards the women. In the occupied Eritrea women in fact took marriage by the traditional custom of dämòz, which was not legally recognized by the Italian state, thus relieving the husband from any legal obligation toward the woman. However, at the same time, a campaign against the putative dangers of miscegenation started in Italy. The Church endorsed the laws which stated the "hybrid unions" had to be forbidden because of "the wise, hygienic and socially moral reasons intended by the State": the "inconvenience of a marriage between a White and a Negro", plus the "increasing moral deficiencies in the character of the children".
In the late 1930s Benito Mussolini became a major ally of Nazi Germany, culminating in the Pact of Steel. The influence of Nazi ideology on Italian Fascism appeared in a 16 February 1938 press release by Mussolini in which some restrictions on Jewish people were suggested. An anti-Semitic press campaign intensified, with Jews blamed for high food prices and unemployment. The Fascist regime assumed an overt racist position with the Manifesto of Race, originally published as Il fascismo e i problemi della razza ("Fascism and the problems of race"), on 14 July 1938 in Il Giornale d'Italia. The Manifesto was then reprinted in August in the first issue of the scientific racist magazine La Difesa della Razza ("The Defense of Race"), endorsed by Mussolini and at the direction of Telesio Interlandi. On 5 August 1938 Mussolini issued another press release, this time acknowledging that restrictions on Jews were going to be enacted. The release noted that "segregating does not mean persecuting", but persecution had in fact begun.
The anti-Semitic metamorphosis of Fascism culminated in the racial laws of 18 September 1938. Although they did not directly threaten Jewish lives, the laws excluded Jews from public education, the military and government, and made it practically impossible for them to pursue most economic activities. Jews could not hire non-Jews. The marriage of Jews to non-Jews were also prohibited.
Julius Evola was an intellectual of war and post-war period. It is believed that Evola was the main Italian theoretician of racism during the 20th century. Evola published two systematic works on racism, including The Blood Myth (1937) and Synthesis of the Doctrine of Race (1941). Furthermore, Evola discussed the subject in a substantial number of articles in several Italian journals and magazines. Evola also introduced the 1937 edition of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, published by Giovanni Preziosi. Evola wrote:
While The Blood Myth aimed at being an impartial review of the history and latest developments of racism theories in Europe, Synthesis of the Doctrine of the Race introduced the concept of spiritual racism. This concept met with the approval of Benito Mussolini. Mussolini was looking for a theoretical justification of racism different from that of biological racism, which was mainstream in Nazi Germany. Evola's brought together several underlying themes of her thought. Among those themes were anti-Darwinism, anti-materialism and anti-reductionism. Anti-Darwinism is the concept of history as regressive, positioning the apex of civilization at the beginning of history. For Evola, race existed on three levels: body race, soul race and spiritual race. The concept was pinned to a transcendent foundation. Evola wrote: "[r]ace and caste exist in the spirit before manifesting themselves in the earthly existence. The difference comes from the top, what refers to it on earth is only a reflection, a symbol." Evola explicitly criticized the Nazi racist view, deeming them "trivial darwinism" or "divinified biologism". For Evola, the Jewish race was not meant to be discriminated for mere biological reasons. In fact, Jewishness was essentially instead a "race of the soul, an unmistakable and hereditary style of action and attitude to life." Evola's spiritual racism was more powerful than biological racism, because it also recognized Jewishness as a spiritual and cultural component which tainted what Evola recognized as the Aryan race. Despite this peculiar theoretical elaboration, Evola's overall description of Jewishness was not particularly different from the common racist stereotypes of this period.
Second World War
During the Second World War, Italians engaged in ethnic cleansing. In the summer and autumn of 1942, as many as 65,000 Italian soldiers destroyed several areas of occupied Slovenia. Many areas were left almost depopulated after the killing and arrest of the residents. Between 1941 and the Grand Council's deposing of Benito Mussolini on 25 July 1943, 25,000 Slovenians (roughly 8% of the population in the Ljubljana area) were put in Italian detention camps.
In order to close Italian borders to all refugees and to expel illegal Jewish immigrants, Italian authorities complied with German requests to deport Jews in the occupied Balkans and French territories.
A pivotal event of the Jewish persecution in Italy during the war was the so-called razzia, or roundup of October 1943, in Rome. On the morning of 16 October 1943, German troops arrested as many as 1259 Jews for deportation to Nazi concentration camps. The Vatican, convents, monasteries and other Catholic homes and institutions had taken pre-emptive actions days prior to hide Jews, resulting in over four thousand escaping deportation.
Mussolini also played upon long-standing racist attitudes against Sicilians, enacting a number of laws and measures directed at anyone born in Sicily/of Sicilian descent. Regarding the treatment of Sicilians under Mussolini's regime, Count Ciano, Mussolini's son-in-law, wrote in his diaries on 4 October 1941: "The internal situation - coming apart in various places - is becoming grave in Sicily...So, then is it worse to be Sicilian than to be Jewish?"
Anti-Roma sentiment exists in Italy, and takes the form of hostility, prejudice, discrimination or racism directed at the Romani people. There's no reliable data for the total number of Roma people living in Italy, but estimates put it between 140,000 and 170,000.
In Italy, many national and local political leaders engaged in rhetoric during 2007 and 2008 that maintained that the extraordinary rise in crime at the time was mainly a result of uncontrolled immigration of people of Roma origin from recent European Union member state Romania. National and local leaders declared their plans to expel Roma from settlements in and around major cities and to deport illegal immigrants. The mayors of Rome and Milan signed "Security Pacts" in May 2007 that "envisaged the forced eviction of up to 10,000 Romani people."
In October 2007, extraordinary anti-immigrant sentiment exploded into violence toward Romanian immigrants and Roma in general. The violence was triggered by the murder of 47-year-old Giovanna Reggiani, a naval captain’s wife, which was attributed to a Romanian immigrant of Roma origin. Reggiani was raped, beaten, left in a ditch, and died the following week. The Italian government responded with roundups of Romanian immigrants and summary expulsions of some two hundred, mostly Roma, disregarding E.U. immigration rules. According to Rome's then Mayor Walter Veltroni Romanians made up 75 percent of those who raped, stole and killed in the first seven months of the year.
In May 2008, an unnamed 16-year-old Romanian girl from a different part of town was arrested for trying to snatch an unattended six-month-old baby. After that mobs in several areas around Naples attacked Roma communities, setting homes alight, and forcing hundreds of Roma to flee. The camp in Ponticelli was set on fire each month between May and July 2008.
According to a May 2008 poll 68% of Italians, wanted to see all of the country's approximately 150,000 Gypsies, many of them Italian citizens, expelled. The survey, published as mobs in Naples burned down Gypsy camps that month, revealed that the majority also wanted all Gypsy camps in Italy to be demolished.
Racism in politics and sports
Actions by the Lega Nord have been criticized as xenophobic or racist by several sources. Italians protested the murder of Burkina Faso native, Abdul Salam Guibre, along with racism in Italy on 20 September 2008. L'Osservatore Romano, the semi-official newspaper for the Holy See, indicated that racism played an important role in the riot in Rosarno. According to a Eurobarometer study, Italians had the third lowest level of "comfort with person of Gypsy origin as neighbour", after Austrians and Czechs.
Following the 2013 nomination of Cécile Kyenge, a Congolese-born Italian immigrant, as Minister of Integration in the government of Enrico Letta, she became subject to several racial slurs by local and national politicians. One of these slurs was made by Roberto Calderoli, a prominent figure of the anti-immigration and populist party Lega Nord. Calderoli claimed that whenever he saw Minister Kyenge, an orangutan came to his mind. During a speech by Kyenge at a meeting of the Democratic Party a few days after Calderoli's slur, some members of the far-right and neo-fascist New Force threw a clump of bananas at the minister.
- Grace Russo Bullaro, 'From terrone to extracomunitario:A snapshot of Italian society in a globalized world,' in Grace Russo Bullaro (ed.), From Terrone to Extracomunitario: New Manifestations of Racism in Contemporary Italian Cinema : Shifting Demographics and Changing Images in a Multi-cultural Globalized Society, Troubador Publishing Ltd, 2010 p.xiv.
- John Foot, Modern Italy, Rev.ed.Palgrave Macmillan, 2014 pp.20ff.
- Michael Alexander, Cities and Labour Immigration: Comparing Policy Responses in Amsterdam, Paris, Rome and Tel Aviv, Rev.ed. Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2012 p.56.
- Foot p.42.
- Alexander p.57.
- Melissa Coburn, Race and Narrative in Italian Women's Writing Since Unification, Fairleigh Dickinson, 2013 p.11.
- Judith Sunderland, L’intolleranza quotidiana La violenza razzista e xenofoba in Italia, 21 March 12011
- Steven Epstein (1 January 2001). Speaking of Slavery: Color, Ethnicity, and Human Bondage in Italy. Cornell University Press. ISBN 978-0-8014-3848-6. Retrieved 27 August 2013.
- Gibson, Mary; Hahn Rafter, Nicole (15 June 2006). "Editors' Introduction". In Lombroso, Cesare. Criminal Man. Duke University Press. pp. 17–. ISBN 978-0-8223-8780-0. Retrieved 27 August 2013.
- Nicole Rafter (1 January 2008). The Criminal Brain: Understanding Biological Theories of Crime. NYU Press. pp. 1–. ISBN 978-0-8147-7656-8. Retrieved 27 August 2013.
- Dr Suman Fernando; Suman Fernando (15 April 2013). Cultural Diversity, Mental Health and Psychiatry: The Struggle Against Racism. Routledge. pp. 63–. ISBN 978-1-135-45270-4. Retrieved 27 August 2013.
- Wiley Feinstein, The Civilization of the Holocaust in Italy: Poets, Artists, Saints, Anti-semites, Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 2003 pp.162f.
- Paul Knepper 'Lombroso and Jewish Social Science,' in Paul Knepper, Per Jørgen Ystehede (eds.),The Cesare Lombroso Handbook, Routledge, 2013 pp.171-185 pp-181ff.
- William Brustein, Roots of Hate: Anti-Semitism in Europe Before the Holocaust, Cambridge University Press, 2003
- Ruth Ben-Ghiat Fascist Modernities: Italy, 1922-1945, University of California Press, 2001 p.262 n.97.
- Stanley G. Payne, A History of Fascism, 1914–1945 , University of Wisconsin Press, 1996 pp.239-240.
- R. J. B. Bosworth,Mussolini, Bloomsbury Publishing, Rev.ed. 2014 pp.123f.
- Piers Brendon, The Dark Valley: A Panorama of the 1930s, Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, 2007 pp.552f.
- Salvatore Garau, Fascism and Ideology: Italy, Britain, and Norway, Routledge, 2015 pp.122-123.
- John Whittam, Fascist Italy, Manchester University Press, 1995 pp.95f.
- Michele Sarfatti, Anne C. Tedeschi, The Jews in Mussolini's Italy: From Equality to Persecution, University of Wisconsin Press, 2006 p.13.
- David I. Kertzer, The Popes Against the Jews: The Vatican's Role in the Rise of Modern Anti-Semitism, Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, 2007 p.266.
- Valentina Pisanty (2006). La difesa della razza: Antologia 1938–1943. Bompiani.
- Racial theories in Fascist Italy by Aaron Gilette
- Dictating Demography: The Problem of Population in Fascist Italy by Carl Ipsen, pg 187
- Duggan, Christopher (2008). The force of destiny : a history of Italy since 1796. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. ISBN 0618353674.
- Hollander, Ethan J. Italian Fascism and the Jews (PDF). University of California. ISBN 0-8039-4648-1.
- "The Italian Holocaust: The Story of an Assimilated Jewish Community". ACJNA.org. 8 January 2008.
- Benito Mussolini By Jeremy Roberts
- Giuseppe Acerbi (2011). Le leggi antiebraiche e razziali italiane ed il ceto dei giuristi. Giuffrè Editore. pp. 33–. ISBN 978-88-14-15571-0. Retrieved 9 August 2013.
- Richard S. Levy (1 January 2005). Antisemitism: A Historical Encyclopedia of Prejudice and Persecution. ABC-CLIO. pp. 585–. ISBN 978-1-85109-439-4. Retrieved 12 August 2013.
- Sergio Luzzatto (5 November 2008). "Pio XI e quel razzismo d'Africa". Corriere della Sera. Retrieved 19 September 2013.
- "Il madamato". Museo virtuale delle intolleranze e degli stermini. Istituto Piemontese per la Storia della Resistenza e della Società Contemporanea "Giorgio Agosti". Retrieved 19 September 2013.
- "Manifesto della Razza". Dizionario di Storia (2011). Treccani. Retrieved 9 August 2013.
- Peter Hayes; John K. Roth (25 November 2010). The Oxford Handbook of Holocaust Studies. Oxford Handbooks Online. pp. 89–. ISBN 978-0-19-921186-9. Retrieved 12 August 2013.
- Mussolini's intellectuals: fascist social and political thought by Anthony James Gregor, Chapter 9
- Rota (2008). Intellettuali, dittatura, razzismo di stato. FrancoAngeli. pp. 57–. ISBN 978-88-568-2094-2.
- J. Evola, Il Mistero del Graal e la tradizione ghibellina dell'Impero, Laterza, Bari 1937 p.182. Evola says also that this was precisely Preziosi's own view. It should also be noted that in speaking of a 'Masonic' conspiracy in such texts, 'Masonic' was often a code word for a secret lobby containing prominent secularized Jewish businessmen. The point is underscored by a recent controversy in Italy where a priest used the word 'Masonic-Jewish lobby', and, in reaction to a public outcry, subsequently changed the reference to 'Masonic', which however retains the old ambiguity in Fascist usage. See 'Don Gelmini, prima attacca poi rettifica,' in La Repubblica, 5/8/2007
- Antonello La Vergata (2005). Guerra e darwinismo sociale. Rubbettino Editore. pp. 189–. ISBN 978-88-498-1458-3.
- Richard S. Levy (1 January 2005). Antisemitism: A Historical Encyclopedia of Prejudice and Persecution. ABC-CLIO. pp. 518–. ISBN 978-1-85109-439-4. Retrieved 12 August 2013.
- Ciano, Galeazzo (1999). Diario 1937-1943 (in Italian). Milano: Rizzoli. p. 542. ISBN 8817115347.
- Thomas Hammarberg, "Memorandum following the visit to Italy on 19–20 June 2008," the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, CommDH(2008)18, para. 26, 28 July 2008
- Amnesty International, The State of the World’s Human Rights 2008: Italy, POL 10/001/2008, June 2008, pp. 171-172
- "Brutal Attack in Rome: Italy Cracks Down on Immigrant Crime Wave," Der Spiegel, 2 November 2007
- Migrant hate fears over Italy gipsy camp fire, The Daily Telegraph, Malcolm Moore, Rome, 14 May 2008
- Violence Against Roma, Human Rights First, 2008 Hate Crime Survey, Italy, p. 6.
- Michael Stewart: The Gypsy 'menace': Populism and the New Anti-Gypsy Politics, Hurst Publishers, 2012, ISBN 9781849042192, p. 15.
- 68% of Italians want Roma expelled - poll, The Guardian, Tom Kington, Rome, 17 May 2008
- Naughton, Philippe; Costello, Miles (15 April 2008). "Silvio Berlusconi: third time lucky?". London: The Times. Retrieved 2010-05-07.
- Horowitz, Jason (17 June 2003). "Italy: Statement On Immigrants Denied". The New York Times. Retrieved 2010-05-07.
- Lewis, Aidan (17 April 2008). "Italy's Northern League resurgent". BBC News.
- Johnston, Bruce (4 August 2004). "Italian mayor fights terror threat with ban on Muslim veils". London: The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 2010-05-07.
- Rogers, Iain (15 April 2008). "League allies may hinder Italy's Berlusconi: reports". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2010-05-07.
- Times Online
- Nick Squires (12 January 2010). "Vatican accuses Italians of racism after southern riots". The Telegraph. Rome.
- Eurobarometer, p. 43
- Squires, Nick (5 October 2008). "Protests in Italy against escalating racism". London: The Telegraph.
- Whitnall, Adam (18 July 2013). "Defamation case opened against racist Italian senator Roberto Calderoli as abuse of black minister continues". The Independent. Retrieved 7 August 2013.
- Scherer, Steve (14 July 2013). "Roberto Calderoli, Italian Politician, Compares First Black Minister Cecile Kyenge To Orangutan". The Huffington Post. Retrieved 7 August 2013.
- Mezzofiore, Gianluca (17 July 2013). "Italian Court Opens Investigation into Roberto Calderoli's Orangutan Slur". International Business Times. Retrieved 7 August 2013.
- Hornby, Catherine (27 July 2013). "Bananas Thrown at Black Italian Minister, Cecile Kyenge, During Speech". The Huffington Post. Retrieved 7 August 2013.
- Williams, Rob (28 July 2013). "Fury after banana thrown at Italy's first black minister Cecile Kyenge in latest racist attack". The Independent. Retrieved 7 August 2013.
- Mackenzie, James (25 Jan 2014). "Outrage in Italy at pig's head sent to Rome synagogue". The REUTERS. Retrieved 29 Sep 2014.
- "Pig heads sent to synagogue, Israeli embassy and museum in Rome". The Global Jewish News. 26 January 2014. Retrieved 29 September 2014.
- Report of the UN Special Rapporteur on Contemporary forms of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance on his visit to Italy 2007
- CERD Concluding observations on Italy, 2008
- European Commission against Racism and Intolerance — 3rd report on Lithuania, 2006