Lithuanian parliamentary election, 2016

Lithuanian parliamentary election, 2016

9 and 23 October 2016

All 141 seats in the Seimas 71 seats needed for a majority   First party Second party Third party   Leader Ramūnas Karbauskis Gabrielius Landsbergis Algirdas Butkevičius Party Peasants and Greens Homeland Union Social Democrats Last election 1 seat, 4.05% 33 seats, 15.75% 38 seats, 19.18% Seats won 54 31 17 Seat change 53 2 21 Popular vote 274,108 (PR) 276,275 (PR) 183,597 (PR) Percentage 22.45% (PR) 22.63% (PR) 15.04% (PR) Swing 18.40% 6.88% 4.14%   Fourth party Fifth party Sixth party   Leader Remigijus Šimašius Valdemar Tomaševski Rolandas Paksas Party Liberal Movement Electoral Action of Poles Order and Justice Last election 10 seats, 8.95% 8 seats, 6.08% 11 seats, 7.63% Seats won 14 8 8 Seat change 4 0 3 Popular vote 115,361 (PR) 69,810 (PR) 67,817 (PR) Percentage 9.45% (PR) 5.72% (PR) 5.55% (PR) Swing 0.50% 0.36% 2.08%

Prime Minister before election Algirdas Butkevičius Social Democrats Prime Minister-designate Saulius Skvernelis Independent

Lithuania
This article is part of a series on the politics and government of Lithuania
Constitution
Executive President Dalia Grybauskaitė Prime Minister Saulius Skvernelis
Legislature Seimas Seimas Palace Speaker: Loreta Graužinienė
Judiciary Constitutional Court Supreme Court
Elections Recent elections President: 2004 2009 2014 Seimas: 2008 2012 2016 Municipal: 2007, 2011, 2015 European: 2004 2009 2014 Referendums Political parties
Administrative divisions Counties Municipalities Elderships
Foreign relations Ministers of Foreign Affairs
Other countries Atlas

Parliamentary elections were held in Lithuania on 9 October 2016, with a second round held on 23 October in the constituencies where no candidate won a majority in the first round of voting.^[1] All 141 seats in the Seimas were up for election; 71 in single-member constituencies elected by majority vote and the remaining 70 in a nationwide constituency based on proportional representation.

The elections were won by the Lithuanian Peasant and Greens Union, which picked up 22.45% of the popular vote and 54 seats, up from just a single seat in the elections four years prior. The success of the party was attributed to voter dissatisfaction with established parties in light of low wages and persistent emigration. Homeland Union, the largest opposition party in the preceeding Seimas, finished a distant second, with the largest share of the national vote but only 31 seats.

Government parties faced a setback in the elections. The Social Democratic Party of Lithuania, which had been the largest party in the Seimas before the elections, finished third, with 17 seats. Their coalition partners, the Labour Party and Order and Justice, fared even worse, picking up 2 and 8 seats, respectively.

Background

The 2012 parliamentary elections were held on 14 October 2012, with the run-off on 28 October. The elections were won by the Social Democratic Party of Lithuania, which took 38 seats in the 141-member Eleventh Seimas.^[2] Social Democrats were joined in the coalition government by Labour, Order and Justice and the Electoral Action of Poles in Lithuania. The Polish party withdrew from the government in 2014.^[3]

The resulting government was headed by the leader of the Social Democrats, Algirdas Butkevičius, as the Prime Minister.

Electoral system

The Seimas has 141 members, elected to a four-year term in parallel voting, with 71 members elected in single-member constituencies and 70 members elected by proportional representation in a single nationwide constituency.^[4] Voting in the elections is open to all citizens of Lithuania who are at least 18-years-old.

Members of the Seimas from the 71 single-member constituencies are elected by a majority vote. A candidate is elected in the first round if he or she obtains an absolute majority of all votes cast (including blank/invalid votes) in given constituency and turnout there is at least 40%. If these criteria are not fullfiled, a run-off between the two highest-placed candidates is held within 15 days. In second round, the candidate who obtains the most votes is elected (an absolute majority is not required), but if turnout in given constitutency is under 40% again, the whole election process there is repeated.^[4]

The remaining 70 seats are allocated to the participating political parties using the largest remainder method. In nationwide constituency party lists need to receive at least 5% (7% for multi-party electoral lists) of the total votes cast (including blank/invalid votes) to be eligible for a seat (irrespective of the number of seats gained in single-member constituencies). Candidates take the seats allocated to their parties based on the preference lists submitted before the elections and adjusted by preference votes given by the voters.^[4]

To be eligible for election, candidates must be at least 25-years-old on the election day, not under allegiance to a foreign state and permanently resident in Lithuania. Persons serving or due to serve a sentence imposed by the court 65 days before the elections are not eligible. Also, judges, citizens performing military service, and servicemen of professional military service and officials of statutory institutions and establishments may not stand for election.^[4] In addition, a person who has been removed from office through impeachment may not be elected.^[5]

Changes before the elections

The 71 single-seat constituencies in Lithuania were drawn soon after independence, based on the principle that the number of voters in each constituency should be between 90 and 110 percent of the average number of voters per constituency. As the demographic situation changed, the law was adjusted to allow a deviation in the range from 80 and 120 percent, in order to avoid major changes to constituency boundaries.

In October 2015, the Constitutional Court of Lithuania decided that the existing system, which allows the largest constituency to be as much as 50% larger than the smallest one, is unconstitutional, since it does not give sufficiently equal weight to all votes. The court stated that the constituencies should be redrawn in such a way that the number of voters in each constituency is between 90 and 110 percent of the average.^[6]

The decision of the Constitutional Court was implemented in December 2015, when the new constituencies were announced. Major changes included two additional constituencies in Vilnius.^[7][8]

Opinion polls

Election outcome
	Parties										Invalid votes, %		Turnout, %
	LSDP	TS-KD	DP	TT	LRLS	LLRA	DK	LVŽS	ŽP	Other
PR vote, %	14.4	21.7	4.7	5.3	9.0	5.5	0.3	21.6	1.9	11.5	4.1		50.6
Polls by Vilmorus for Lietuvos Rytas
	Parties										Won't vote	Don't know	No answer
	LSDP	TS-KD	DP	TT	LRLS	LLRA	DK	LVŽS	ŽP	Other
2–10 September 2016[9]	16.0	9.2	5.1	4.8	2.7	2.0	0.2	12.6	1.5	9.5	12.9	20.7	2.7
1–10 July 2016[10]	14.2	10.8	7.0	5.5	5.9	2.6	-	12.0	2.5	1.6	14.9	21.6	2.0
3–10 June 2016[11]	16.2	10.9	8.2	6.3	3.6	2.9	-	13.0	2.6	1.4	11.4	21.0	1.8
5–13 May 2016[12]	16.2	8.9	8.2	5.3	8.9	2.8	-	12.5	2.4	0.5	13.8	18.3	2.2
6–15 April 2016[13]	15.7	8.0	7.7	8.4	9.6	2.5	0.8	11.1	1.8	0.8	12.1	19.5	2.0
8–13 March 2016[14]	21.2	10.2	7.9	7.7	10.4	3.2	0.3	7.1	2.3	0.5	11.3	18.1	1.8
11–19 February 2016[15]	23.0	9.9	6.8	7.4	8.7	3.6	0.7	7.1	2.5	0.8	10.9	16.5	2.1
14–20 January 2016[16]	20.7	9.1	7.7	7.7	9.6	3.6	0.2	5.9	1.4	0.6	11.8	18.5	3.2
4–11 December 2015[17]	23.5	8.4	9.2	7.0	9.8	2.9	0.3	6.0	1.9	0.6	10.5	17.5	2.4
5–14 November 2015[18]	24.3	9.9	9.2	7.8	11.0	2.7	0.1	6.3	1.6	0.9	10.7	13.7	1.8
Polls by "Spinter tyrimai" for Delfi.lt
	Parties										Won't vote	Don't know	No answer
	LSDP	TS-KD	DP	TT	LRLS	LLRA	DK	LVŽS	ŽP	Other
19–27 September 2016[19]	15.6	13.7	5.2	4.9	5.0	4.2	-	14.0	-	9.6	16.3	11.5
23–30 August 2016[20]	17.2	10.5	6.6	5.1	6.3	4.7	-	12.4	2.0	7.0	15.8	12.4
19–26 July 2016[21]	15.8	10.7	7.3	6.2	6.1	4.8	-	13.4	2.3	5.3	16.1	12.0
21–29 June 2016[22]	16.8	10.5	7.6	7.5	6.3	4.3	-	12.2	2.3	5.3	14.3	12.9
19–26 May 2016[23]	15.5	9.3	7.5	7.6	6.6	4.3	-	11.5	3.0	3.0	16.7	15.0
19–25 April 2016[24]	17.2	7.5	7.1	8.0	15.5	4.5	-	11.3	2.1	2.0	14.1	10.7
15–25 March 2016[25]	18.8	10.6	5.9	9.0	15.0	4.5	-	8.2	1.7	2.3	14.4	9.6
19–27 February 2016[26]	19.6	10.5	7.0	7.4	14.2	4.8	-	6.6	2.0	1.6	15.4	10.9
20–27 January 2016[27]	20.9	9.9	7.4	8.6	13.0	4.0	-	6.8	2.2	1.8	25.4		-
12–18 December 2015[28]	23.0	9.5	7.0	8.5	13.5	4.0	-	5.5	1.8	3.0	16.5	7.7	-
16–23 November 2015[29]	22.4	10.6	7.0	9.1	14.6	3.5	-	5.6	2.0	2.3	14.6	8.3	-
Preceding elections
	Parties										Invalid votes, %		Turnout, %
	LSDP	TS-KD	DP	TT	LRLS	LLRA	DK	LVŽS	ŽP	Other
Seats	38	33	29	11	10	8	7	1	-	3	4.2		52.9
PR vote, %	18.4	15.1	19.9	7.3	8.6	5.8	8.0	3.9	-	8.9

Campaign

Announcement

On 7 April 2016 the President of Lithuania, Dalia Grybauskaitė, officially announced 9 October 2016 as the election date. The announcement, which came into effect on 9 April 2016, launched the election campaign, allowing the potential participants to register for the elections, raise funds and campaign in public.^[30]

Campaign financing

In January 2016, the Central Electoral Commission announced the spending limits for political campaigns in 2016. A party participating in the elections in the nationwide constituency could spend a total of 770 thousand euros on the campaign. Participants in the election races in single-seat constituencies could spend between 18 and 22 thousand euros, depending on the size of the constituency. As a result, a political party with candidates in every single seat constituency could spend just over 2.2 million euros on its election campaign.^[31]

Only citizens of Lithuania can contribute financially to the election campaigns. Each citizen can contribute up to 7,570 euros to a candidate, as long as their total contributions during the year do not exceed 10% of their stated annual income. A candidate can contribute up to 15,140 euros to their own election campaign.^[32]

Participating parties

23 political parties were eligible to participate in the elections, having submitted their membership rolls before 1 March 2016, in compliance with legal requirements.^[33] 16 political parties registered for the elections before the deadline on 5 August 2016. 12 of them participated in the elections independently, while the remaining 4 formed two separate electoral coalitions, bringing the total number of electoral lists to 14, down from 18 in 2012.^[34][35] The electoral lists were assigned numbers in a random draw on 25 August.^[36]

Over the year preceding the election, six political parties consistently polled above the 5 percent threshold for seats in the nationwide constituency: Social Democrats, Homeland Union, Liberal Movement, Peasant and Greens Union, Labour, and Order and Justice.

After their election victory in 2012, the Social Democrats led the governing coalition, with Algirdas Butkevičius as Prime Minister. Butkevičius, his government and the Social Democrats maintained very high approval ratings among the public and performed well in the elections to the European parliament in 2014 (where they finished a close second) and the municipal elections in 2015 (where they won the most mandates and mayoral posts).^[37] Their ratings suffered in 2016, damaged by a corruption scandal related to construction in protected areas near Druskininkai, but the Social Democrats remained the most popular party, according to opinion polls.^{[38][39][40][41]} The electoral program of the party was focused on spreading the benefits of the growing economy by increasing salaries and retirement benefits.^[42]

Homeland Union was the largest opposition party in the Eleventh Seimas. Andrius Kubilius, who had led the first government in modern Lithuanian history to survive a full term in office, did not seek another term as leader of the party. In 2015 he was replaced by Gabrielius Landsbergis, the grandson of the patriarch of the party, Vytautas Landsbergis.^[43] The party surprised political observers by winning the largest share of the vote in the European Parliament elections in 2014 and tended to outperform the opinion polls due to the higher participation rate among their supporters.^[44] The program of the party promised higher quality public services and reduced bureaucratic waste, new well-paid employment opportunities and improved public education.^[45]

The Liberal Movement had emerged as one of the main political forces in Lithuania, finishing a close third in the European Parliament elections in 2014 and the municipal elections in 2015. Until May 2016, the party was consistently the second most popular party in opinion polls (behind only the Social Democrats) and was seen as the most likely coalition partner for both the Social Democrats and Homeland Union.^[44][46] The party lost most of its support after its leader, Eligijus Masiulis, was accused of taking a substantial bribe from one of the leading business groups in the country.^[47][48] Masiulis promptly resigned and was eventually replaced by the mayor of Vilnius, Remigijus Šimašius.^[49] As part of its platform, the party proposed a smaller government, lower taxes (especially VAT) and more flexible labor relationships. The party also expressed support for same-sex unions in Lithuania.^[50]

Lithuanian Peasant Popular Union rebranded itself as the Lithuanian Peasant and Greens Union (LVŽS) in 2012. Led by businessman Ramūnas Karbauskis, the party received 6.6% of the vote in the European Parliament elections in 2014, earning a single mandate, and emerged as a dark horse in the electoral race in the spring of 2016. The rise of LVŽS was attributed to the popularity of Karbauskis, who had been active in campaigning against alcohol, and their lack of involvement in political scandals.^[51] LVŽS was further boosted by the announcement that Saulius Skvernelis, a Minister of Interior in Butkevičius Cabinet and one of the most popular politicians in Lithuania, would head the party's electoral list in the elections, without joining the party.^[52][53] Before the elections, the party ruled out the possibility of participating in a ruling coalition which involved Labour or Order and Justice.

The Labour Party was led in the elections by Valentinas Mazuronis, an MEP who had originally been elected to the European Parliament on the electoral list of Order and Justice. Labour is the second-largest party in Lithuania in terms of members, but had been plagued by accusations of fraudulent bookkeeping, and by the departure of its founder Viktor Uspaskich. Before the elections, the party promised to fight the influx of refugees into the country, despite the number of refugees actually settled in Lithuania being in single digits.^[54] The party also proposed higher pensions and minimum wage, a higher non-taxable allowance, reduced VAT rates on food and medicine and one-off payouts to those reaching the age of maturity.^[45]

Order and Justice, led by the former President of Lithuania Rolandas Paksas, was also involved in a corruption scandal before the elections. Paksas, who is barred from being elected to the Seimas, was suspected of accepting a bribe from Gedvydas Vainauskas, a media magnate, in exchange for favors related to construction permits.^[44] The party proposed to link salaries and pensions to an inflation index, exempt reinvested profits from corporate income taxes and to create new employment opportunities. Generous payments on childbirth were proposed to address demographic issues.^[45]

In total, 1416 candidates competed for Seimas seats in the elections, with 673 participating in the electoral races in single-seat constituencies.^[55]

Debates

As before every elections, televised debates took place on the national television channel. The debates took place over 4 weeks from 13 September to 6 October. Representatives from the 14 electoral lists were split into three groups for each week of debates, debating on different days of the week on the same topic. The topics for the four weeks of debates were: economy, demographics, justice and social policy.^[56] The parties were mostly represented by the leaders of their electoral lists, with support from other members.

In May 2016, five political parties (the Social Democrats, the Liberal Movement, the Homeland Union, Labour and the Peasant and Greens Union) agreed to participate in the debates together, leaving out Order and Justice.^[57] The agreement remained in place even after the corruption scandal involving the leader of the Liberal Movement, Eligijus Masiulis, and the subsequent slide in the party's ratings.^[58]

The main party debate on economy took place on 14 September 2016. Prime Minister Butkevičius and Gabrielius Landsbergis of the Homeland Union clashed over the responsibility for the high poverty rate, while all parties identified what they saw as the main issues facing the economy. Kęstutis Daukšys of the Labour Party reiterated the promise from the party's electoral program to increase the salaries and pensions while Saulius Skvernelis, representing the Peasant and Greens Union, labeled such promises as populism and proposed to remove it from political decision making by indexing the minimum wage and pensions to economic indicators. At the same time Skvernelis proposed and Landsbergis supported reforms to the system of personal taxation, while Eugenijus Gentvilas of the Liberal Movement proposed wide-ranging tax cuts, having asserted that high taxes are one of the main stumbling blocks for economic progress in the country.^[59] Experts polled by the National Television judged the debates as a marginal victory for Butkevičius and Social Democrats.^[60]

The main party debate on demographics took place on 22 September 2016. Butkevičius defended the Social Democrats' record in government, which was attacked by the Homeland Union. All parties proposed reforms to the education sector and other measures they see as necessary to reverse the emigration trends. Experts polled by the National Television judged the debates as a marginal victory for Homeland Union, represented by Landsbergis, with Peasant and Greens, represented by Skvernelis, in a close second place. An improved performance from Skvernelis, compared to the first debate, was noted.^[61]

The main party debate on justice took place on 29 September 2016. Experts polled by the National Television judged the debates as a marginal victory for Peasants and Greens, represented by Skvernelis, closely followed by the Homeland Union. Social Democrats, on the other hand, were criticized for failing to propose new ideas, instead of pointing out how situation was already improving.^[62]

The main party debate on social policy took place on 6 October 2016. Candidates presented their positions on social issues and health. At the end of the debate the representatives gave their final statements to voters. Experts polled by the National Television criticized the lack of substantial proposals for reforms in the debate, but judged Peasants and Greens to have performed most convincingly. Homeland Union again finished close second, with Landsbergis' final speech considered as the most successful.^[63]

Results

The election was a surprise victory for Peasant and Greens Union, which won 54 seats in the parliament, after failing to clear the electoral threshold of 5% and winning just one seat in the preceding elections. Including the two candidates that won their single-member constituencies as independents but ran on the party's electoral list in the nationwide constituency, this represents the largest tally by any party in Lithuania in 20 years.^[64] Analysts attributed the victory to the desire by the electorate to see new faces in the parliament, in light of low wages and rampant emigration.^[65][66]

Homeland Union won the largest share of the vote (22.63%) and 20 mandates in the nationwide constituency, improving on their result in 2012. However, a disappointing performance in single-member constituencies, where they picked up only 11 seats, left the party a distant second with 31 seats, two fewer than in the previous elections.

Government parties suffered a major setback in the elections. Social Democrats, who had been leading the polls consistently since the previous elections, finished third with 15.04% of the vote and 17 seats. Order and Justice finished with 5.72% and 8 seats (down from 7.63% and 11 seats), while Labour Party, which had led the popular vote in the elections of 2012, failed to clear the electoral threshold for proportionally allocated seats and picked up only two seats in the single-member constituencies. The failure of government parties has been attributed to sluggish economic growth, scandals that had surfaced over the months preceding the elections and the adoption of a new labour code that was deeply unpopular with voters.^[67][68][69]

Single-member constituencies – seats won in the first round

Single-member constituencies – first place after the first round

Single-member constituencies – seats won after the second round

Aftermath

Soon after the results of the first round of voting were clear, Mazuronis resigned as the leader of the Labour Party, while Paksas resigned as the leader of Order and Justice.^[72][73] After the second round of voting, Butkevičius also offered his resignation as the chairman of the Social Democrats, but his resignation was rejected. However, Butkevičius ruled out standing for reelection as the chairman in 2017.^[74]

Soon after the election results became clear, the victorious Peasants and Greens started coalition consultations with Homeland Union and the Social Democrats.^[75] Peasants and Greens expressed their desire for a broad coalition involving both parties, a concept that Homeland Union ruled out. On 9 November, Peasants and Greens signed a coalition agreement with the Social Democrats, under which the Social Democrats would be allocated 3 of the 14 seats in the cabinet, while Peasants and Greens got the right to nominate the prime minister and the speaker of the Seimas.^[76]

The newly elected Twelfth Seimas is convened for its first session on 14 November 2016 and elected Viktoras Pranckietis as the Speaker of the Seimas.^[77] On 22 Novemeber, President Dalia Grybauskaitė appointed Saulius Skvernelis as the prime minister.^[78]

References

Elections and referendums in Lithuania
Presidential elections	1993 1997–98 2002–03 2004 2009 2014
Parliamentary elections	1920 1922 1923 1926 1936 1940 1947 1951 1955 1959 1963 1967 1971 1975 1980 1985 1990 1992 1996 2000 2004 2008 2012 2016
European elections	2004 2009 2014
Referendums	1991 1992 (May) 1992 (Jun) 1992 (Oct) 1994 1996 (Oct) 1996 (Nov) 2003 2008 2012 2014
See also: Elections in the Klaipėda Region • Elections in Central Lithuania