James Pillans

Bust of Prof James Pillans by Peter Slater, 1852, Old College, University of Edinburgh
Pillans home at 22 Abercromby Place, Edinburgh
Pillans home at 43 Inverleith Row, Edinburgh
Grave of James Pillans, St Cuthberts Churchyard, Edinburgh

Prof James Pillans (1778–1864) LLD FRSE was a Scottish classical scholar and educational reformer.

Early life

Son of James Pillans, was born at Edinburgh in April 1778. His father was a printer, an elder in the Anti-Burgher branch of the Scottish Secession Church, of Adam Gib, and a liberal in politics. Pillans was educated at the Royal High School, Edinburgh, under Alexander Adam, of whom he subsequently contributed a biography to the Encyclopædia Britannica. He was second in the rector's class, after his close friend Francis Horner; another classmate was John Archibald Murray.[1]

His father wished to apprentice him to a paper-stainer, but Pillans went on to Edinburgh University, where he graduated M.A. on 30 January 1801. He became a pupil of Andrew Dalzel, was influenced by Dugald Stewart, and attended the chemistry lectures of Joseph Black. He was a member of the "dialectic society" founded by "Burgher" divinity students in the university. After graduation he acted as tutor, first to Thomas Francis Kennedy at Dunure, Ayrshire, next in a family in Northumberland, where he had the opportunity of speaking French. He then moved to Eton, as a private tutor.[1]


On the death of Adam (13 December 1809), Pillans offered himself as a candidate for the rectorship of the Edinburgh High School. With the support of Robert Blair, Lord Avontoun he was chosen over Luke Fraser, the internal candidate, despite his Whig politics which counted against him with the Tory town council. In January 1810 Pillans entered on his duties in the old high school, on Infirmary Street, with a class of 144 boys. At the outset he used the tawse, which he later gave up.[1]

Pillans introduced a version of the Bell–Lancaster monitorial system, and his class doubled its numbers. His reputation attracted pupils from far and wide.[1] Another Lancasterian at the High School at this period was James Gray.[2]

Pillans developed the teaching of classical Greek, which had been begun by Christison in Adam's time; and encouraged the study of classical geography.[1] His pupil John Brown Patterson became known as a classical scholar; other pupils were Robert Christison and Cosmo Nelson Innes.[3][4][5]


In 1820 the chair of "humanity and laws" (in effect Latin) at Edinburgh University was vacated by the death of Alexander Christison. Pillans was elected his successor, and occupied the chair for over 53 years. He carries over some of the ideas which he had applied in the High School. He still taught elementary Latin. He believed that universities should supply elementary teaching in classics, and opposed, with Philip Kelland and others, the institution (May 1855) of an entrance examination to the junior Greek class, though he was in favour of an examination for admission to higher classes. He enlarged the conventional range of classical authors proposed for study.[1]

Pillans lectured on "universal grammar" and the laws of the twelve tables. A prize was awarded for English recitation,; among those who gained it was Fox Maule, who joined the class when he was quartered with his regiment in Edinburgh Castle. Pillans was one of the first to teach the revised pronunciation of Latin, though in practice he conformed to the usual Scottish way.[1]


During vacations Pillans investigated education in Scotland, and compared it with other countries. He made tours to inspect the systems of Prussia, France, Switzerland, and Ireland.[1]

During the 1830s Pillans is listed as living at 22 Abercromby Place in Edinburgh's Second New Town.[6]

Pillans gave evidence to the committee of the House of Commons on education in 1834: on religious education (p. 218), infant schools (p. 227), and teacher training (p. 231).[7] He was an early advocate for compulsory education, wrote in defence of the classical training, and had advanced views on popular education. He became president of the Watt Institution and School of Arts, inaugurating in 1854 the statue of James Watt then in Adam Square.[1]

Last years

Pillans resigned at the close of his eighty-fifth year, and took formal leave of the university on 11 April 1863. The degree of LL.D. was conferred upon him on 22 April.

He died at his residence, 43 Inverleith Row, on 27 March 1864. He was buried on 1 April in the graveyard of St Cuthbert's Church, Edinburgh.[1] His grave lies at the west end of the north extension and is beginning to erode.


Pillans wrote for the Edinburgh Review from 1804, after an introduction by Horner. Unfavourable comments on the Juvenal translation of Francis Hodgson earned him a swipe in English Bards and Scotch Reviewers.[8][9]

Educational writings

A letter from Pillans appeared in Jeremy Bentham's Chrestomathia (1815).[10] It was entitled Successful application of the new system to language-learning, and dated 1814; it mentions the use of chalk and blackboard in teaching geography. It was followed by a letter from his Edinburgh High School colleague James Gray.[11]

Letters on the Principles of Elementary Teaching (Edinburgh, 1827; 1828; 1855), based on correspondence with his former pupil Kennedy of Dunure, was the statement of Pillans of his method based on his work at the High School, with criticism of the educational state of Scotland. This book proved controversial, being attacked in Letters addressed to the Parochial Schoolmasters of Scotland (1829),[12] reviewed negatively in the Edinburgh Literary Journal which defended Pillans.[13] In the same year a long article in the Quarterly Review vol. LXXVII on elementary teaching called the work of Pillans "very sensible" (p. 114), while advocating the "Bell system" of the National Society schools (p. 120), i.e. Andrew Bell's version of the monitorial system.[14] The review was in fact by Bell, who had met Pillans not long before, and felt that the variant of the "system" that was described in the Letters did not do justice to his own ideas.[15] Pillans then defended himself and the rival claims of Joseph Lancaster's system; and was endorsed by the Eclectic Review.[16][17] The principles brought up by Pillans entered the secondary literature.[18]

Contributions to the Cause of Education (1856), dedicated to Lord John Russell, included reprints of earlier works. It also comprised articles in the Edinburgh Review, minutes of evidence, and other material. The blackboard method of "chalk and talk" teaching is also mentioned.[1][9]

Pillans published also:[1]

Classical studies and geography

His time at Eton led Pillans to value Latin verse composition, which in Scotland was a lost art. A volume of the compositions of his class appeared as Ex Tentaminibus Metricis … in Schola Regia Edinensi … electa, Edinburgh, 1812, dedicated to Joseph Goodall. It was favourably noticed in the Edinburgh Review (November 1812), but criticised by Robert Southey (or Walter Scott) in the Quarterly Review (December 1812).[1][9]


Pillans married Helen, second daughter of Thomas Thomson, minister of Dailly, Ayrshire, sister of Thomas Thomson and John Thomson of Duddingston, but was early left a widower without issue.[1]



  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15  "Pillans, James". Dictionary of National Biography. London: Smith, Elder & Co. 1885–1900.
  2. Jackson, Peter. "Gray, James". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/11341. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  3. Ritchie, Lionel Alexander. "Patterson, John Brown". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/21576. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  4. White, Brenda M. "Christison, Sir Robert". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/5370. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  5. Matthew, H. C. G. "Innes, Cosmo Nelson". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/14428. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  6. http://digital.nls.uk/directories/browse/pageturner.cfm?id=83401407&mode=transcription
  7. Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge (Great Britain) (1835). The Quarterly Journal of Education. pp. 213–243. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  8. Baron George Noël Gordon Byron; Thomas Moore (1832). The works of Lord Byron. J. Murray. p. 255. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  9. 1 2 3 Morse, Elizabeth J. "Pillans, James". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/22282. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
  10. Foakes p. 205 note 47.
  11. Jeremy Bentham (1841). The Works of Jeremy Bentham, now first collected: under the superintendence of his executor, John Bowring ... W. Tait. pp. 59–63. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  12. Letters addressed to the parochial schoolmasters of Scotland, concerning the new method of tuition: Containing strictures on Professor Pillans' "Principles of elementary teaching," and suggestions respecting the means of accomplishing a strict division of labour in conducting promiscuous schools. Anonymous, attributed to James Hunter.
  13. The Edinburgh literary journal; or, Weekly register of criticism and belles lettres. Constable and Co. 1829. pp. 146–8. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  14. The Quarterly review. 1829. pp. 99–143. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  15. Robert Southey; Charles Cuthbert Southey (1844). The Life of the Rev. Andrew Bell: ... Prebendary of Westminster, and Master of Sherburn Hospital, Durham. Comprising the History of the Rise and Progress of the System of Mutual Tuition. J. Murray. pp. 336–7. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  16. James Pillans (1856). Contributions to the Cause of Education. Longman, Brown, Green & Longmans. pp. 82–6. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  17. The Eclectic review. vol. 1-New [8th]. 1830. p. 144. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
  18. William Ross (1858). The teacher's manual of method; or, The general principles of teaching and school-keeping. p. 187. Retrieved 14 February 2013.

 This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: "Pillans, James". Dictionary of National Biography. London: Smith, Elder & Co. 1885–1900. 

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the 12/3/2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.