Frances Erskine Inglis, 1st Marquise of Calderón de la Barca

Frances "Fanny" Erskine Inglis, later the Marquise of Calderón de la Barca (Edinburgh, Scotland, 1804 – Madrid, Spain, 1882), was a Scottish 19th-century travel writer best known for her 1843 account, Life in Mexico, which is widely regarded by historians as one of the most influential Latin American travel narratives of the 19th century.^[1][2]

Early life

Inglis was born in Edinburgh, Scotland in 1804, the 5th child of her Scottish, upper-class parents,.^[3] Her father was a distinguished lawyer ^[4] and her mother came from a wealthy Scottish family who had profited from distillery.^[3] When Inglis’ father’s law firm suffered from bankruptcy, her family moved to Normandy, France, and later to Boston, after his death and her mother’s remarriage in 1831.^[1] During this time, Inglis traveled to Italy as a young girl to complete her education.^[5]

In Boston, she and her family opened a school for girls,^[4] where Inglis worked as a schoolteacher. However, the decline of the school led her family to move to New Brighton, in Staten Island, New York, a place of particular interest to diplomats, such as the Spanish minister to the United States, Ángel Calderón de la Barca, retreating there from Washington, D.C.’s hot summers.^[1][3] Inglis and Ángel met in 1836 through the mutual acquaintance of prominent historian, William Hickling Prescott, who had brought Ángel to New York due to interest in his Spanish source materials.^[3] On September 24, 1838, Inglis and Ángel Calderón de la Barca married, and Frances Erskine Inglis became Frances “Fanny” Calderón de la Barca.^[3] The couple moved to Mexico in 1839, when Ángel became Spanish minister to Mexico as part of Spain’s attempt to recognize Mexico’s independence.^[4] They resided in Mexico for the next two years, during which Fanny Calderón de la Barca wrote the letters that would eventually comprise her 1843 travel book, Life in Mexico. ^[6]

Career

Frances Erskine Inglis is best known for her book La vida en México durante una residencia de dos años en este país (Life in Mexico, During a Residence Of Two Years In That Country)^[7][8] which was published under the name Madame Calderón de la Barca in Boston and London in 1843. She also wrote El agregado en Madrid o Bocetos de la Corte de Isabel II (1856).

La vida en México is a classic of its genre, one of the few travelogues written by a European woman living in Mexico during the early years of Mexican Independence.

Life in Mexico

Life in Mexico is a travel narrative published by William Hickling Prescott in 1843, which contains 54 letters Fanny Calderón wrote during her two years in Mexico (October 1839-February 1842).^[4][6] It describes the politics, people, and landscape of Mexico through the eyes of a Spanish diplomat's wife, thus providing a unique lens into the culture, which is why Prescott applauded its ethnographical and historiographical significance.^[1][4][6]

Overall, the account documents class distinctions of Mexican women, perspectives on Indians, and the tumultuous political atmosphere, including two revolutions.^[2][4]

In terms of politics, Calderón pokes fun at the male elite through sarcasm and irony. Appalled by the violence, she focuses primarily on the role of ordinary people rather than political leaders in the revolution, such as the women fleeing the bloodshed and the statesmen and literary figures of Mexican society.^[2] Concluding that Spain is integral to Mexico's functioning as an independent country, Calderón implies an imperialist motive in her writing.^[4][6] She further critiques the patriarchy in contrasting the conditions faced by men and women in the Mexican Catholic Church. Whereas monks are given comfortable conditions, nuns are placed into prison-like confinement, a reality that Calderón strongly opposes.^[2][6]

Writing in the vein of Romanticism, Calderón describes the Mexican landscape through picturesque elements, identifying with historical figures such as Spanish conquistador Cortés and his indigenous mistress, Malinche. She paints the terrain as an almost Biblical Eden of unexploited resources that would contribute to the United States' objective to invade Mexico.^[4][6]

As a woman with Scottish, American, Spanish, and Mexican ties, Calderón crosses the boundaries of nationality, being drawn to Mexican concert balls and indigenous dress. However, she maintains a level of superiority due to her upper-class status, which colors her perceptions of the lower classes.^[5][6][9]

Historical Significance

Although Calderón's narrative is highly regarded today by historians as the only 19th-century travel account of Mexico written by a woman, it was negatively received by Mexicans and Spaniards in Mexico after its publication due to Calderón's "offensive" commentary on Mexican society.^[2][3][9] Nonetheless, in the United States, Life in Mexico, with its detailed descriptions of Mexican people and terrain, became instrumental in the Mexican–American War of 1846-48. In fact, the United States government consulted with Calderón and Prescott personally to gain intel that would eventually lead to the United States' invasion of Mexico.^[6]

The Attaché in Madrid

Published in New York in 1856 under the male pseudonym of a young German diplomat, Calderón’s The Attaché in Madrid is, by far, her lesser known travel account. Although it was used as part of Spanish history, it has become more or less forgotten. This is partially due to its publication under a male name, which would have diminished the uniqueness of the female perspective present in Life in Mexico, since many male-authored travel accounts from writers such as Washington Irving had already been written on 19th-century Spain. Because her husband was now a diplomat in Spain, Calderón could not speak openly about Spanish life and had to be careful to conceal her identity.^[5]

Much like in Life in Mexico, Calderón describes the “charitable institutions” formerly of interest to her under the guise of the curiosity of her male persona’s mother. She uses “his” family members’ interests as justifications for descriptions that might not have otherwise been significant to a male travel writer. But simultaneously, she also utilizes this male identity to speak on topics inaccessible to females of her class, such as the San Isidro Festival, the Burial of the Sardine and bullfights. In addition, by offering the “German” outsider’s perspective, she frees her narrative from the typical mid-19th-century United States discourse on Spanish decadence, instead showing her German Catholic narrator’s admiration of Spain.^[5]

Although she uses “anonymity” and “maleness” to justify her point of view, Calderón actually reconstructs the concept by offering multiple perspectives contrary to the primary theme of “domination” in male travel writing. For instance, as if in response to claims in male narratives about the infidelity of Spanish women, Calderón ’s narrator defends their honor. In effect, his “masculine voice” is only one amongst others, male and female, Spanish and foreigner, providing a balanced view that distinguishes her from authentic male travel writers.^[5]

Despite being poorly received in comparison to Life in Mexico, The Attaché in Madrid did experience a brief resurgence in 1898, after Calderón’s death, having been circulated from the United States to Havana, Cuba, and discovered by a Spanish artillery captain, Cristobal de Reyna. He considered it a “valuable historical document” and published it under the name, “Don Ramiro”, fully accepting its maleness and unaware of its true authorship.^[5]

Later life

After returning from Mexico in 1843, Fanny Calderón and her husband resided in Washington, D.C. for 9 years before he was reassigned to Spain, where he died in 1861. During that time, she converted to Catholicism in 1847.^[4] Following her husband’s death, Calderón served as the tutor for Infenta Isabel, the daughter of Isabella II, for two decades. In 1873, she was awarded the title, Marquesa de Calderón de la Barca. She died in Madrid, Spain on February 6, 1882 at the age of 77.^[3][5]

References

External links

• Works by Frances Erskine Inglis, 1st Marquise of Calderón de la Barca at Project Gutenberg
• Works by or about Frances Erskine Inglis at Internet Archive
• Works by Frances Erskine Inglis, 1st Marquise of Calderón de la Barca at LibriVox (public domain audiobooks)